Loss prevention: Customer loaners and rentals
AutomotiveArticleNovember 16, 2026
Consider a case where a customer brought a vehicle in for service at a dealership. The job required the service department to keep the vehicle overnight, and the customer requested a loaner vehicle. The service manager smiled and handed the customer the keys to a dealership loaner. Later that evening, the customer picked up two friends and they were off on a “road trip” that included drinking and driving. The loaner vehicle was involved in a collision that paralyzed one person and severely injured several others. The dealership now faces a multimillion-dollar settlement. You may ask yourself:
- What about the customer’s insurance; isn’t it primary?
- Why is the dealer responsible for this accident?
- Could this happen to me?
The answers to these questions depend on individual state law. You should consult with your dealership’s corporate counsel about your state’s law regarding liability exposures arising out of vehicle ownership, negligent entrustment and dangerous instrumentality. Consider the following three guidelines that can help reduce your liability exposure:
Risk avoidance: Don't provide loaners at your dealership
Service writers can offer to assist customers with finding a rental car. The dealership should have agreements with local car rental companies to provide vehicles to their customers at a pre-arranged rate. Courtesy vans can also be used to take customers to and from work or home.
Risk transfer: Leave car loaning to the professionals
Another guideline to consider is the risk management technique referred to as “risk transfer.” The objective is to transfer the risk to someone else. The ideal arrangement is to leave the task of providing loaners to the professionals — car rental companies.
Many dealerships furnish on-site space for these companies who then provide vehicles to their customers. Rental companies are accustomed to dealing with important issues such as driver selection, rental contracts, insurance and driver’s licenses. They often provide better service to the customer and insulate you from a serious liability exposure in the process. One word of caution — use a reputable, properly insured rental company.
Risk retention: Mitigate the exposures of loaned vehicles
The third guideline is referred to as “risk retention,” meaning that you make a conscious decision to retain the exposure yourself. If you decide to retain this risk, there are still some ways to help protect yourself. Some things to consider:
- Take advantage of loaners provided by your manufacturer whenever possible.
- Use written agreements or contracts such as “loaner or borrowed vehicle agreement” or rental contracts. (Sample agreements may be available from local or state dealer associations.)
- The agreements or contracts should transfer financial responsibility of loss (liability and property damage) to the customer.
- Agreements/contracts should indemnify and hold harmless the dealership for any type of loss while the vehicle is in the care, custody, and control of the customer.
- Limit authorized drivers to those persons signing the contract or agreement.
- Obtain a copy of a valid driver’s license with photo ID.
- Decline to rent or loan vehicles to customers who are clearly intoxicated or impaired.
- Obtain evidence of insurance (e.g., an insurance card or policy) and verify coverage is current by telephoning insurance agent/company.
- Limit the operation of the rental or loaner to a specified radius and time (e.g., 25 miles and five days).
- Refuse to rent or loan vehicles to customers under 25 years of age.
- Inspect vehicles at the time of rental or loan and upon return for damage, mileage and missing equipment.
- Maintain loaner vehicles according to manufacturer’s recommendations and document all maintenance activities.
- Consult with your dealership’s legal counsel about your state’s laws relating to ownership and entrustment of vehicles.
Remember, laws on vehicle ownership, negligent entrustment and dangerous instrumentality vary widely and are state-specific. Contact your Zurich representative or consult your state and local dealer associations for additional information.
To learn more about Zurich’s products and Risk Engineering services, click here, contact your Zurich representative, or call us at 1-800-840-8842 ext. 7449.
